With more than three decades of experience in law enforcement, I have witnessed the justice system’s pendulum swing, often disproportionately impacting African Americans. From sentencing disparities and mass incarceration to the excessive use of force, African Americans have borne the brunt of policies that have led to adverse and often devastating outcomes.
Before implementing policies with far-reaching consequences, it is imperative to conduct racial impact assessments. These evaluations provide critical insights into how proposed laws and policies might affect different racial and ethnic groups. Armed with such data, legislators can work to mitigate disparities and promote equity in communities of color.
We are far from being a color-blind society. Racial diversity requires acknowledgment and celebration of differences between racial groups. In recent years, diversity, equity, and inclusion have become polarizing topics, but recognizing our diversity is the first step toward valuing the differences that exist within and between racial identities.
Consider the proposed ban by the Food and Drug Administration on menthol-flavored cigarettes—a policy that exemplifies this disparity. While not a ban on all cigarettes, it specifically targets menthol cigarettes, favored by 81% of African American smokers. Such a ban would disproportionately impact African American communities based solely on flavor preference.
To be clear, I am not advocating for smoking. The health risks associated with tobacco are well-documented. However, I am advocating for fairness in policy administration. Menthol, an additive in these cigarettes, has no conclusive evidence linking it to cancer. Moreover, menthol is present in common products like toothpaste, mouthwash, cough drops, and candy, none of which face calls for prohibition.
Procedural justice demands fairness and transparency in decision-making. Key principles include unbiased decision-making, transparency, and providing citizens with an opportunity to voice their concerns. If a regulation disproportionately impacts one racial group, it is imperative to conduct a racial impact assessment to ensure fairness and equity.
President Obama’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing emphasized that trust between law enforcement and communities is “key to the stability of our communities and the safe and effective delivery of policing services.” Building trust and legitimacy remains essential not only for policing but for all aspects of governance.
Historically, well-intentioned bans in the United States have often led to unintended consequences. The Eighteenth Amendment, which prohibited alcohol, resulted in the rise of speakeasies and unregulated moonshine. Organized crime flourished, and public health suffered. The 18th Amendment was eventually repealed by the 21st Amendment in 1933.
Similarly, poorly designed policies in the 1980s and 1990s, such as mandatory minimum sentences and the disparity in crack versus powder cocaine penalties, disproportionately affected African Americans and Hispanics. These laws led to mass incarceration, tearing families apart and exacerbating racial inequities. African Americans, who comprise 13% of the U.S. population, account for 37% of the prison population—a glaring imbalance.
The sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine is a striking example of injustice. While crack cocaine requires powder cocaine to be produced, possessing just 5 grams of crack carried the same sentence as 500 grams of powder cocaine- 5 years imprisonment. By 1990, federal drug sentences for African Americans were, on average, 49% higher than those for white offenders.
Addressing issues like tobacco use or drug addiction requires evidence-based approaches rooted in harm reduction, not criminalization. Instead of banning menthol cigarettes, policymakers should focus on education, treatment, and counseling to empower individuals to make healthier choices.
S
ystemic disparities demand a multifaceted approach grounded in fairness, transparency, and evidence-based solutions. We must strive for policies that promote equity and justice for all communities, ensuring that unintended consequences no longer perpetuate cycles of harm and inequality.
Leave a Reply